Back to Blog
FinancialNovember 15, 20267 min read

What Is a Good Cap Rate for a Rental Property?

A good cap rate is typically 4% to 10% depending on market and risk. Learn the cap rate formula, how it differs from cash-on-cash return, and the expenses investors forget.

By Dandre Noah
What Is a Good Cap Rate for a Rental Property?

A duplex near you lists for $380,000 and the listing agent calls it a "great investment." Before you believe them, you need one number: the cap rate. It is the fastest way to compare rental properties against each other and against every other investment competing for your money.

The cap rate formula is simple: Net Operating Income / Purchase Price. A property generating $28,000 of net operating income on a $380,000 price is a 7.4% cap rate. Generally, 4% to 6% is typical in hot coastal markets, 6% to 8% in balanced markets, and 8% to 10%+ in higher-risk or declining areas. Our Cap Rate Calculator does the math, including the expense line items that sellers conveniently leave out.

What Cap Rate Actually Measures

Cap rate is the property's unleveraged yield: the return you would earn if you paid all cash, before any mortgage. That makes it the right tool for comparing properties to each other on equal footing, and for comparing real estate to other income investments like bonds or dividend stocks.

It deliberately ignores financing on purpose. Two investors buying the same building at different down payments get different cash returns, but the building's intrinsic earning power is identical. Cap rate isolates that intrinsic number.

Cap Rate = (Gross Rent - Operating Expenses) / Property Price x 100

Gross rent means gross potential rent. Responsible underwriting starts by deducting a vacancy allowance, typically 5% to 10%, before subtracting operating expenses like property taxes, insurance, maintenance, management, and utilities the owner pays.

Worked Example: The Duplex

The $380,000 duplex rents for $2,600 per unit monthly.

  • Gross annual rent: $62,400
  • Vacancy allowance at 6%: -$3,744
  • Property taxes: -$6,200
  • Insurance: -$2,400
  • Maintenance and capex reserve at 8% of rent: -$4,992
  • Management at 8% of collected rent: -$4,695
  • Net operating income: $40,369

Cap rate: $40,369 / $380,000 = 10.6%. That is a strong number, and it should make you suspicious rather than excited. Double-check the rent comps and expense estimates, because deals that look too good usually are hiding something.

What Counts as "Good" by Market

There is no universal good cap rate because the number prices risk. A 4.5% cap rate on a renovated building in Austin may be a fine deal; a 4.5% cap rate on a tired property in a shrinking town is overpriced.

  • 4% to 6%: expensive metros, strong appreciation expectation, low perceived risk. You are paying for safety and growth, not cash flow.
  • 6% to 8%: the sweet spot for most individual investors in stable mid-size markets. Cash flow plus reasonable appreciation.
  • 8% to 10%+: higher-risk markets, older buildings, or seller distress. The yield compensates you for vacancy risk, deferred maintenance, or thin tenant demand.

Compare the cap rate to your cost of money. If investment mortgages run near 7%, a 5% cap rate property loses money on cash flow unless you pay down heavily. The gap between cap rate and mortgage rate determines whether leverage helps or hurts you, which is exactly what our Cash Flow Calculator quantifies.

Cap Rate vs. Cash-on-Cash Return

Cap rate assumes all cash. Cash-on-cash return measures your actual dollars after financing.

Take the same duplex with 25% down ($95,000) and a $285,000 loan at 7.25% for 30 years. Annual debt service is about $23,300. Cash flow after debt: $40,369 - $23,300 = $17,069. Cash-on-cash return: $17,069 / $104,700 (down payment plus closing) = 16.3%.

The cap rate says the property earns 10.6% unleveraged. The cash-on-cash says your deployed capital earns 16.3% leveraged. Both are true; they answer different questions. Use cap rate to screen properties, cash-on-cash to evaluate your deal.

For the full financing picture, model the loan with our Amortization Calculator and test rate options on the Loan Comparison Calculator. Buyers weighing a bigger down payment against points should also run the Mortgage Points Calculator.

The Expenses Sellers Hide

The most common way listings inflate cap rates is by omitting real expenses. Recalculate with all of these before trusting any advertised number:

  • Vacancy: 5% to 10% even in strong markets
  • Management: 8% to 10% of collected rent even if you self-manage, because your time has value and you might hire it out later
  • Capital expenditure reserve: roofs, HVAC, and water heaters are not repairs, they are sinking funds. Budget $150 to $300 per unit monthly
  • Turn costs: cleaning, paint, and advertising between tenants
  • Non-reimbursed utilities and HOA dues if applicable

A property advertised at 8% often lands at 5.5% after honest expenses. Also watch insurance quotes, which have climbed sharply in many states, and verify actual tax assessments instead of the seller's historical figure, since the reassessment after sale can jump.

Common Mistakes

1. Confusing cap rate with total return. Cap rate excludes appreciation, principal paydown, and depreciation tax benefits. Depreciation alone shelters a big share of rental income; our Depreciation Calculator shows the schedule. Total return usually runs 2 to 5 points above cash yield.

2. Buying a high cap rate in a dying market. A 12% cap rate is worthless if rents fall 10% and vacancy doubles. Cheap yield is often expensive risk.

3. Ignoring interest-only alternatives. Some investors use Interest-Only Mortgage structures to keep payments low during a value-add renovation, accepting zero principal paydown for maximum cash flow. It is a legitimate strategy, just one that raises leverage risk.

4. Forgetting PMI and jumbo thresholds. Above 20% down, PMI disappears. In expensive markets the loan can cross the conforming limit and become a Jumbo Loan with different pricing. Both change cash-on-cash math even though cap rate is unaffected.

External Resources

People Also Ask

Is a 7% cap rate good?

Yes, in most markets a 7% cap rate is considered good for a residential rental. It suggests the property cash-flows reasonably against a roughly 7% mortgage environment without excessive risk. Whether it is good for you depends on local comps and your financing terms.

Is a higher cap rate always better?

No. Higher cap rates price higher risk: weaker markets, older buildings, less reliable tenants. A 10% cap rate in a declining city can underperform a 5% cap rate in a growing metro once vacancy, maintenance, and appreciation are counted.

Does cap rate include the mortgage?

No, and that is deliberate. Cap rate is the unleveraged return, which lets you compare properties and markets on equal footing. Once you pick a property, cash-on-cash return and our cash flow tools account for your specific financing.

What expenses go into net operating income?

Everything except the mortgage: property taxes, insurance, management, maintenance, capex reserves, utilities the owner pays, HOA dues, and a vacancy allowance. Debt service is excluded because cap rate measures the property, not the loan.

real-estatecap-raterental-propertyinvesting

Try These Calculators

Put the math from this article into practice with our free tools.

Command Palette

Search calculators and pages